Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Performative Bafflement's avatar

I think the two main reasons to be skeptical that utopias are possible now are:

1) Lots of people have tried and failed, and those failures are recent enough to be documented (with your post here an example of that documentation)

2) Governments are bigger, more capable, and more willing and able to limit technologically mediated change that could help create a utopia

Per 2, I can create a utopia - we need to legalize gengineering somewhere, and let market forces act so that people can pay to have much smarter, healthier, happier, and more attractive kids. When parents can choose the level of neuroticism (low), IQ (high), conscientiousness (high), etc their kids will have, those kids will be able to create better and more utopian societies together than their parents, and provided gengineering capabilities keep increasing, that can be a virtuous spiral.

But gengineering isn't legal anywhere. And it likely won't be legal anywhere for a good amount of time, and if it were legal somewhere, odds are enough people in other countries would agitate about it and try to make it illegal, via soft or hard power. Crabs in a bucket.

Similarly, if you let people sort themselves by things other than wealth and income. Take the people in the top decile of combined IQ, capability, conscientiousness, and mental health and let them form their own society and government. They'll get closer than anyone else to creating a better and more utopian society over time - but wait, we can't do that. There's no process to do it, it's called "secession" and it's a dirty word to all governments everywhere. That top decile pays a lot of taxes, after all. Also, it's probably not diverse or inclusive enough, so they'll all get cancelled or embargoed by trade partners or whatever, and this is also why we can't have tracking by ability in schools in the US.

Back in 18th-19th century times, the federal government was much weaker. Local governments were much weaker. You had a credible means to create a mini society that followed different rules, both legally and socially. You can't do any of that now.

If we did have some means to make more federated enclaves of different legal schemes, then we could have the requisite sorting by ability and inclination, and sorting by technologically-allowed-and-mediated change like gengineering, to actually try to do something different and better. But good luck convincing current governments to give up the cream of their current tax-paying crop and let them go form weird Prospera-like enclaves and have super-babies together.

Jonny Bates's avatar

I moved back after a decade abroad and am shocked by our malaise and cynicism. CA is approaching UK/EU levels. It's sadder to see in our art/entertainment too. I blame the intellectual climate more than economic. We've never had more leverage and are close to multiplying it. Regulation aside, we have plenty of frontiers in that every one of our paradigms must be reinvented. Physically we have the space and resources to build Babylons and Shangri-Las. More importantly, America is the world's best hope rn. The stakes are far higher than ourselves, and we need to be riffing on the fantastical.

Enjoyed your take but expected your vision before it ended. You could draw a compelling one with the thought you've given here. I wrote one through the lens of health you might find useful.

https://jonnyabates.substack.com/p/restoring-american-health-and-our

53 more comments...

Ready for more?