I think the two main reasons to be skeptical that utopias are possible now are:
1) Lots of people have tried and failed, and those failures are recent enough to be documented (with your post here an example of that documentation)
2) Governments are bigger, more capable, and more willing and able to limit technologically mediated change that could help create a utopia
Per 2, I can create a utopia - we need to legalize gengineering somewhere, and let market forces act so that people can pay to have much smarter, healthier, happier, and more attractive kids. When parents can choose the level of neuroticism (low), IQ (high), conscientiousness (high), etc their kids will have, those kids will be able to create better and more utopian societies together than their parents, and provided gengineering capabilities keep increasing, that can be a virtuous spiral.
But gengineering isn't legal anywhere. And it likely won't be legal anywhere for a good amount of time, and if it were legal somewhere, odds are enough people in other countries would agitate about it and try to make it illegal, via soft or hard power. Crabs in a bucket.
Similarly, if you let people sort themselves by things other than wealth and income. Take the people in the top decile of combined IQ, capability, conscientiousness, and mental health and let them form their own society and government. They'll get closer than anyone else to creating a better and more utopian society over time - but wait, we can't do that. There's no process to do it, it's called "secession" and it's a dirty word to all governments everywhere. That top decile pays a lot of taxes, after all. Also, it's probably not diverse or inclusive enough, so they'll all get cancelled or embargoed by trade partners or whatever, and this is also why we can't have tracking by ability in schools in the US.
Back in 18th-19th century times, the federal government was much weaker. Local governments were much weaker. You had a credible means to create a mini society that followed different rules, both legally and socially. You can't do any of that now.
If we did have some means to make more federated enclaves of different legal schemes, then we could have the requisite sorting by ability and inclination, and sorting by technologically-allowed-and-mediated change like gengineering, to actually try to do something different and better. But good luck convincing current governments to give up the cream of their current tax-paying crop and let them go form weird Prospera-like enclaves and have super-babies together.
Thank you for the thoughts. The idea that we are prisoners of our far better and more qualified legal structures is an interesting point and quite possibly a contributor to it at least today if not in the early 20th century.
"Lots of people tried and failed..." What does this mean in a world of 8 billion? How many are lots? Or perhaps a better line of questioning: what is the number of tried "cultures" versus untried ones? How well-trodden is the spectrum of culture and community structures, especially given the contemporary range of knowledge and technology resources?
The worst part of it is, even in this world of 8B, states and top-level government has increased in power so much that this may not be possible even in the developing world. Lots of African countries, as one example, pay China for the panopticon surveillance capabilities they've developed on their own people, so the African leaders can spy on and be the boot on the face of their own citizens forever.
But absolutely, from a theoretical perspective, the spectrum of "attempted" cultures is absolutely dwarfed by the infinite possible cultures. The real fun part is imagining where are the local attractors in that space that we can't get to now, because people generally suck in large numbers, but COULD get to those further-off culture places with a higher IQ, higher conscientiousness, more cooperative subset of people? Whether that subset gets there by simple selection, gengineering, or even machine / AI enhancements doesn't really matter.
But how to reach a point where forming those subset and enclaves is possible again? I can really only see it happening in a "frontier" society, so IMO, we need a thriving space colonization society for it to be able to happen again. I don't see it happening on earth, with the current scope and level of developement of the governments here.
I moved back after a decade abroad and am shocked by our malaise and cynicism. CA is approaching UK/EU levels. It's sadder to see in our art/entertainment too. I blame the intellectual climate more than economic. We've never had more leverage and are close to multiplying it. Regulation aside, we have plenty of frontiers in that every one of our paradigms must be reinvented. Physically we have the space and resources to build Babylons and Shangri-Las. More importantly, America is the world's best hope rn. The stakes are far higher than ourselves, and we need to be riffing on the fantastical.
Enjoyed your take but expected your vision before it ended. You could draw a compelling one with the thought you've given here. I wrote one through the lens of health you might find useful.
There are still some glimmers, seasteading and charter cities come to mind. There’s a commune in Ithaca NY that’s interesting. It’s a capital-intensive endeavor, though.
The one example I kept thinking about while reading your post was the Khmer Rouge and how they strived to achieve what they saw as the perfect form of communism and they ended up massacaring a quarter of the Cambodian population.
Absolutely. And Lenin's disastrous attempt to end money (quickly followed by the "New Economic Policy"), and his forced collectivization of farms and murder of kulaks. The number of deaths is staggering, in the tens of millions.
As far as I can tell from my experience of studying architecture, I feel strongly that both in academia and in practice, the central theme is that of encouraging collective action and collaborative living. The idea of utopia is not thrown around too much but I think that is a good thing, perhaps it demonstrates that we have learned to be more humble and grounded towards even ‘noble’ ambitions. I think the general vibe is more on the side of slouching towards rather than directly creating utopia.
My guess is there are all sorts of little attempts to create utopias all over the place; they just don't get the same attention as before. But the bigger issue that our technical prowess meant that we had the power to pursue utopian dreams in the 20th century, and terrible results of those utopian dreams continue to haunt us.
I hope so, either we're stuck under a deluge of info such that these things get buried, or there isn't a sustained belief that we can even create utopias. I fear it's the latter. The haunting of the communist regimes for sure is a major reason today, though the utopians died out even towards the end of the 19th century.
To be a true Utopia that Utopia must, necessarily, outcompete opposing or, at least, alternative systems. i.e. from a Darwinian perspective, it needs to be an evolutionarily stable strategy and a good one at that. Today, we have seen so many try and fail that the evidence appears pretty conclusive that many of the traits that we all believe should be part of our Utopia are actually inherently unstable. Utopia appears to be a logical impossibility, a contradiction in terms. Human beings are denied the possibility of Utopia for so long as they are human beings.
I came across the link to this post in another article, which I can no longer remember. The article below was also linked in it, and both of your posts were the same day. Guess it was Utopia Day in my feed. Hazards of opening links and then closing the original article.
Thought provoking stuff! I'm curious as to why you omitted the hippie communes of the 1960s and 1970s; those seem like utopian community experiments to me, but maybe I'm thinking of them differently.
Mostly only because they felt too inward looking rather than trying to model a new way to live to the whole world. It felt a pulling back than a pushing forward, though admittedly it's not a precise distinction.
Ah, gotcha, thanks for the clarification! I see where you're coming from and I agree.
Perhaps that's another stage in the process, then. People saw the problems with earlier utopias and felt they had to prove the model inwardly and practically first before proselytizing it and declaring it correct. Which, come to think of it, isn't a bad idea.
The kids are totally down for new utopian experiments. They just need good leadership. Those leaders don’t seem to be emerging. Maybe you can help them out.
Very interesting- so many utopias seem to have foundered on the question of who gets to exercise power. Effective altruism would seem to be yet another example of this.
I definitely agree that the lack of frontiers is a major factor dampening utopian (or extropian) thinking and especially practice. While I applaud efforts to create free zones, it's incredibly hard to sustain in a world saturated with governments and nation states. My goal is to stay alive long enough -- or to be revived in the future -- when we can get off this planet at reasonable cost in large numbers. That will be time for social and economic experimentation to flourish.
First, thanks for the charts, Rohit, they're most useful.
Beyond that, yes, no, not really, we can't get there from here.
Let's look at your last paragraph. Your last sentence: "It is worth asking why this form of optimism is no longer around." YES. But I've got doubts about the first sentence of that paragraph: "The spirit of pioneering ambition is perhaps our best features as a species." I know what the words mean, and I have half-a-hunch what you mean by the sentence, and I'm not buying it.
I live in an intellectual world where evolutionary psychology is important. I don't buy it, but I take it seriously. In THAT world your sentence is most easily read as an assertion about our biological nature. I don't think that pioneering ambition is somehow in our genes. But, for example, I'm willing to believe that an exploratory urge is in our genes, and not only ours, but in many animal species. And I'm quite willing to believe that that urge enters into the construction of pioneering ambition.
What do I mean by that, construction? As a crude analogy, think of chess. On the one hand we have the rules of the game, the 8 by 8 board, the different pieces, and the legal moves. You have to know that in order to play the game at all. Think of that as analogous to our biological nature. In order to play even a halfway decent game of chess you need to learn some tactics and strategy; those things are defined over the basic rules, but cannot be reduced to them. That's cultural evolution.
And that's where we get pioneering ambition. That takes us to your next sentence: "We only seem to get it in glimpses as you glance through history, seemingly at random as if a capricious muse bestows it on us, outside our control." But it seems to crop up most strongly in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. I once asked my humanist colleagues: When did we start thinking about the future as a time and place when things would be different from they are now, when they would be better, and made so by effort we can undertake now? That's what they told me (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/2021/07/when-did-future-become-site-for-human.html). The American Revolution started in 1776, the French Revolution a decade later. Note that the American Constitution contained a procedure for making amendments because the framers believed that the future would be different in consequential ways.
Why then? You mention the Enlightenment. Yes, but it didn't come out of nowhere. There's a history there, a lot of cultural evolution. The same with the Industrial Revolution. How are the cognitive underpinnings of those developments constructed out of the "raw stuff" of biological human nature? Hardly anyone is even asking the question. But it's the sort of thing David Hays and I gave careful thought to in elaborating our theory of cultural ranks (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/search/label/cultural%20ranks). That's just the barest beginning but it does provide a way of thinking about how something like pioneering ambition might be constructed.
Beyond that, well, it's complicated. Walt Disney was optimistic about the future and perhaps did more to promote the idea of a technology-fueled quasi-utopian future than any other single person. You can see his vision in a short promotional film he made in 1966, a few months before he died. In that film (https://youtu.be/UEm-09B0px8?si=5tnQh4-zh52qdWm-) he lays out his vision for Experimental Prototype Community Of Tomorrow (EPCOT). What actually got built as EPCOT is far less interesting. After Walt died the world that had nurtured that vision fell apart, though not because Disney died. For all sorts of reasons, some of which you mention.
We can't go back. We need to figure out a new vision (or visions) for the future. One way I have of thinking about that is something I call Kisangani 2150 (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/search/label/Kisangani2150). Why that name? It's derived from New York 2140, Kim Stanley Robinson's novel about the world in 2140. It's neither utopian or dystopian. But it's believable. My idea is to take the world, more or less, run it forward 10 years and center the story in Kisangani. Why Kisangani? Because it's deep in the Congo Basin, which is a very different part of the world from New York. Also, there's literary resonance. Kisangani is the location of the Inner Station in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness. That, as you may recall, is where Kurtz went mad. And there's music, which I explain in the post where I first entertained the idea: Kisangani 2150, or Reconstructing Civilization on a New Model, https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/2019/07/kisangani-2150-or-reconstructing.html
Basically, we have to rethink EVERYTHING. No time to waste.
On the Enlightenment and thoughts about the improvability of humanity, I especially like Richard Tarnas's beautifully written book, The Passion of the West Mind.
Interesting article, and shows quite a wide span of reading and research by you, Rohit. Was an engaging read.
Some places where I’m not fully sure if I agree, but a comments section probably isn’t the place for it. :)
One thing, though: I recently interviewed someone trying to build what I think is a utopian socialism: bit.ly/raahi-protovillage-1 ; so perhaps it is a matter of what news interest us and is filtered in / out in general knowledge vs whether such movements exist? A sort of filtering bias?
I think the two main reasons to be skeptical that utopias are possible now are:
1) Lots of people have tried and failed, and those failures are recent enough to be documented (with your post here an example of that documentation)
2) Governments are bigger, more capable, and more willing and able to limit technologically mediated change that could help create a utopia
Per 2, I can create a utopia - we need to legalize gengineering somewhere, and let market forces act so that people can pay to have much smarter, healthier, happier, and more attractive kids. When parents can choose the level of neuroticism (low), IQ (high), conscientiousness (high), etc their kids will have, those kids will be able to create better and more utopian societies together than their parents, and provided gengineering capabilities keep increasing, that can be a virtuous spiral.
But gengineering isn't legal anywhere. And it likely won't be legal anywhere for a good amount of time, and if it were legal somewhere, odds are enough people in other countries would agitate about it and try to make it illegal, via soft or hard power. Crabs in a bucket.
Similarly, if you let people sort themselves by things other than wealth and income. Take the people in the top decile of combined IQ, capability, conscientiousness, and mental health and let them form their own society and government. They'll get closer than anyone else to creating a better and more utopian society over time - but wait, we can't do that. There's no process to do it, it's called "secession" and it's a dirty word to all governments everywhere. That top decile pays a lot of taxes, after all. Also, it's probably not diverse or inclusive enough, so they'll all get cancelled or embargoed by trade partners or whatever, and this is also why we can't have tracking by ability in schools in the US.
Back in 18th-19th century times, the federal government was much weaker. Local governments were much weaker. You had a credible means to create a mini society that followed different rules, both legally and socially. You can't do any of that now.
If we did have some means to make more federated enclaves of different legal schemes, then we could have the requisite sorting by ability and inclination, and sorting by technologically-allowed-and-mediated change like gengineering, to actually try to do something different and better. But good luck convincing current governments to give up the cream of their current tax-paying crop and let them go form weird Prospera-like enclaves and have super-babies together.
Thank you for the thoughts. The idea that we are prisoners of our far better and more qualified legal structures is an interesting point and quite possibly a contributor to it at least today if not in the early 20th century.
"Lots of people tried and failed..." What does this mean in a world of 8 billion? How many are lots? Or perhaps a better line of questioning: what is the number of tried "cultures" versus untried ones? How well-trodden is the spectrum of culture and community structures, especially given the contemporary range of knowledge and technology resources?
The worst part of it is, even in this world of 8B, states and top-level government has increased in power so much that this may not be possible even in the developing world. Lots of African countries, as one example, pay China for the panopticon surveillance capabilities they've developed on their own people, so the African leaders can spy on and be the boot on the face of their own citizens forever.
But absolutely, from a theoretical perspective, the spectrum of "attempted" cultures is absolutely dwarfed by the infinite possible cultures. The real fun part is imagining where are the local attractors in that space that we can't get to now, because people generally suck in large numbers, but COULD get to those further-off culture places with a higher IQ, higher conscientiousness, more cooperative subset of people? Whether that subset gets there by simple selection, gengineering, or even machine / AI enhancements doesn't really matter.
But how to reach a point where forming those subset and enclaves is possible again? I can really only see it happening in a "frontier" society, so IMO, we need a thriving space colonization society for it to be able to happen again. I don't see it happening on earth, with the current scope and level of developement of the governments here.
I moved back after a decade abroad and am shocked by our malaise and cynicism. CA is approaching UK/EU levels. It's sadder to see in our art/entertainment too. I blame the intellectual climate more than economic. We've never had more leverage and are close to multiplying it. Regulation aside, we have plenty of frontiers in that every one of our paradigms must be reinvented. Physically we have the space and resources to build Babylons and Shangri-Las. More importantly, America is the world's best hope rn. The stakes are far higher than ourselves, and we need to be riffing on the fantastical.
Enjoyed your take but expected your vision before it ended. You could draw a compelling one with the thought you've given here. I wrote one through the lens of health you might find useful.
https://jonnyabates.substack.com/p/restoring-american-health-and-our
It got too long so I thought I would leave it for another day, but thank you!
There are still some glimmers, seasteading and charter cities come to mind. There’s a commune in Ithaca NY that’s interesting. It’s a capital-intensive endeavor, though.
Those are ideals too, and a good thing, though they all seem so small in their dreams. I hope there's many more.
You never know, Neom could pan out.
The one example I kept thinking about while reading your post was the Khmer Rouge and how they strived to achieve what they saw as the perfect form of communism and they ended up massacaring a quarter of the Cambodian population.
Absolutely. And Lenin's disastrous attempt to end money (quickly followed by the "New Economic Policy"), and his forced collectivization of farms and murder of kulaks. The number of deaths is staggering, in the tens of millions.
Yup.
As far as I can tell from my experience of studying architecture, I feel strongly that both in academia and in practice, the central theme is that of encouraging collective action and collaborative living. The idea of utopia is not thrown around too much but I think that is a good thing, perhaps it demonstrates that we have learned to be more humble and grounded towards even ‘noble’ ambitions. I think the general vibe is more on the side of slouching towards rather than directly creating utopia.
I don't know that it's good, I do think ambition is useful and necessary. And I loved Brad's book! https://www.strangeloopcanon.com/p/slouching-towards-utopia
My guess is there are all sorts of little attempts to create utopias all over the place; they just don't get the same attention as before. But the bigger issue that our technical prowess meant that we had the power to pursue utopian dreams in the 20th century, and terrible results of those utopian dreams continue to haunt us.
I hope so, either we're stuck under a deluge of info such that these things get buried, or there isn't a sustained belief that we can even create utopias. I fear it's the latter. The haunting of the communist regimes for sure is a major reason today, though the utopians died out even towards the end of the 19th century.
Various silicon valley adjacent types are trying both the commune thing:
https://neighborhoodsf.com/
And the new town thing:
https://www.edgeesmeralda.com/
Maybe not as ambitious as you might like, but directionally relevant, no?
This is also an interesting study about this subject: https://books.google.cm/books?id=25aUbOSwQ44C
I think there are still many Utopian approaches out there, in fact I’ve made an effort to collect them (the ones that are available to be found)
https://agartha.one
To be a true Utopia that Utopia must, necessarily, outcompete opposing or, at least, alternative systems. i.e. from a Darwinian perspective, it needs to be an evolutionarily stable strategy and a good one at that. Today, we have seen so many try and fail that the evidence appears pretty conclusive that many of the traits that we all believe should be part of our Utopia are actually inherently unstable. Utopia appears to be a logical impossibility, a contradiction in terms. Human beings are denied the possibility of Utopia for so long as they are human beings.
I came across the link to this post in another article, which I can no longer remember. The article below was also linked in it, and both of your posts were the same day. Guess it was Utopia Day in my feed. Hazards of opening links and then closing the original article.
https://www.noemamag.com/chasing-utopia-startup-style/?utm_source=tldrnewsletter
Thought provoking stuff! I'm curious as to why you omitted the hippie communes of the 1960s and 1970s; those seem like utopian community experiments to me, but maybe I'm thinking of them differently.
Mostly only because they felt too inward looking rather than trying to model a new way to live to the whole world. It felt a pulling back than a pushing forward, though admittedly it's not a precise distinction.
Ah, gotcha, thanks for the clarification! I see where you're coming from and I agree.
Perhaps that's another stage in the process, then. People saw the problems with earlier utopias and felt they had to prove the model inwardly and practically first before proselytizing it and declaring it correct. Which, come to think of it, isn't a bad idea.
The kids are totally down for new utopian experiments. They just need good leadership. Those leaders don’t seem to be emerging. Maybe you can help them out.
To the promised land!
Very interesting- so many utopias seem to have foundered on the question of who gets to exercise power. Effective altruism would seem to be yet another example of this.
I definitely agree that the lack of frontiers is a major factor dampening utopian (or extropian) thinking and especially practice. While I applaud efforts to create free zones, it's incredibly hard to sustain in a world saturated with governments and nation states. My goal is to stay alive long enough -- or to be revived in the future -- when we can get off this planet at reasonable cost in large numbers. That will be time for social and economic experimentation to flourish.
First, thanks for the charts, Rohit, they're most useful.
Beyond that, yes, no, not really, we can't get there from here.
Let's look at your last paragraph. Your last sentence: "It is worth asking why this form of optimism is no longer around." YES. But I've got doubts about the first sentence of that paragraph: "The spirit of pioneering ambition is perhaps our best features as a species." I know what the words mean, and I have half-a-hunch what you mean by the sentence, and I'm not buying it.
I live in an intellectual world where evolutionary psychology is important. I don't buy it, but I take it seriously. In THAT world your sentence is most easily read as an assertion about our biological nature. I don't think that pioneering ambition is somehow in our genes. But, for example, I'm willing to believe that an exploratory urge is in our genes, and not only ours, but in many animal species. And I'm quite willing to believe that that urge enters into the construction of pioneering ambition.
What do I mean by that, construction? As a crude analogy, think of chess. On the one hand we have the rules of the game, the 8 by 8 board, the different pieces, and the legal moves. You have to know that in order to play the game at all. Think of that as analogous to our biological nature. In order to play even a halfway decent game of chess you need to learn some tactics and strategy; those things are defined over the basic rules, but cannot be reduced to them. That's cultural evolution.
And that's where we get pioneering ambition. That takes us to your next sentence: "We only seem to get it in glimpses as you glance through history, seemingly at random as if a capricious muse bestows it on us, outside our control." But it seems to crop up most strongly in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. I once asked my humanist colleagues: When did we start thinking about the future as a time and place when things would be different from they are now, when they would be better, and made so by effort we can undertake now? That's what they told me (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/2021/07/when-did-future-become-site-for-human.html). The American Revolution started in 1776, the French Revolution a decade later. Note that the American Constitution contained a procedure for making amendments because the framers believed that the future would be different in consequential ways.
Why then? You mention the Enlightenment. Yes, but it didn't come out of nowhere. There's a history there, a lot of cultural evolution. The same with the Industrial Revolution. How are the cognitive underpinnings of those developments constructed out of the "raw stuff" of biological human nature? Hardly anyone is even asking the question. But it's the sort of thing David Hays and I gave careful thought to in elaborating our theory of cultural ranks (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/search/label/cultural%20ranks). That's just the barest beginning but it does provide a way of thinking about how something like pioneering ambition might be constructed.
Beyond that, well, it's complicated. Walt Disney was optimistic about the future and perhaps did more to promote the idea of a technology-fueled quasi-utopian future than any other single person. You can see his vision in a short promotional film he made in 1966, a few months before he died. In that film (https://youtu.be/UEm-09B0px8?si=5tnQh4-zh52qdWm-) he lays out his vision for Experimental Prototype Community Of Tomorrow (EPCOT). What actually got built as EPCOT is far less interesting. After Walt died the world that had nurtured that vision fell apart, though not because Disney died. For all sorts of reasons, some of which you mention.
We can't go back. We need to figure out a new vision (or visions) for the future. One way I have of thinking about that is something I call Kisangani 2150 (https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/search/label/Kisangani2150). Why that name? It's derived from New York 2140, Kim Stanley Robinson's novel about the world in 2140. It's neither utopian or dystopian. But it's believable. My idea is to take the world, more or less, run it forward 10 years and center the story in Kisangani. Why Kisangani? Because it's deep in the Congo Basin, which is a very different part of the world from New York. Also, there's literary resonance. Kisangani is the location of the Inner Station in Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness. That, as you may recall, is where Kurtz went mad. And there's music, which I explain in the post where I first entertained the idea: Kisangani 2150, or Reconstructing Civilization on a New Model, https://new-savanna.blogspot.com/2019/07/kisangani-2150-or-reconstructing.html
Basically, we have to rethink EVERYTHING. No time to waste.
Thanks for the soapbox.
On the Enlightenment and thoughts about the improvability of humanity, I especially like Richard Tarnas's beautifully written book, The Passion of the West Mind.
Interesting article, and shows quite a wide span of reading and research by you, Rohit. Was an engaging read.
Some places where I’m not fully sure if I agree, but a comments section probably isn’t the place for it. :)
One thing, though: I recently interviewed someone trying to build what I think is a utopian socialism: bit.ly/raahi-protovillage-1 ; so perhaps it is a matter of what news interest us and is filtered in / out in general knowledge vs whether such movements exist? A sort of filtering bias?
I think you’ll you enjoy the conversation. :)
Comments is absolutely the place for it - disagree away!